I'm winding up a trip en famille to the two largest French cities in North America, Montreal and Quebec City. I've been to both cities before, but this was the first time I brought my family along.
The biggest challenge was to attempt to balance the needs of four different people. I love walking around in cities, but my family has less interest in that than I do. I like French cuisine and usually can strike a good balance between quality and price. It was much more difficult this time than ever before, thanks to the weak US dollar. So, we made compromises.
As it turns out, we had four outstanding dinners. Three were in Quebec City and one was in the Chinatown of Montreal. I'm not really surprised about this, since I have always found wonderful food in Quebec City and we managed to do so even when we watched our expenses. By contrast, Montreal is much broader in scope and has a much wider range of dining possibilities. I've had spectacular food in Montreal on past visits, but have also had mediocre dinners. We did okay on this visit to Montreal, but we were definitely alert to the high costs of dinner in Canada and stayed away from the high end places.
It turned out that Chinatown in Montreal hit all of the right notes. On this trip, I relied a lot on Google to get both dinner possibilities and advance reviews. This was a big help. For example, I'd eaten well in Montreal's Chinatown before, but it had been a long time ago and I really had no idea what restaurants to pick. Enter Google. I simply went to Google, entered the words Montreal Chinatown Restaurants and up popped a few reasonable possibilities. We ended up at Maison Kam Fung. It was on the second floor of a business building, so the restaurant itself was a bit hard to find. Happily, we eventually found the magic escalator that took us to the proper floor, unlike the elevator, which was closed for the night.
The food there was excellent. The menu offered all kinds of choices, so we settled on a group portion of wonton soup, steamed shrimp dumplings, spring rolls and two main dishes. We had a bit of a wait for the soup, but is was worth it. The soup was hot and very tasty, with plenty of wonton to go around. The shrimp dumplings were equally good, though we were surprised they came without a sauce. No problem, we simply used the sweet and tart sauce that came with the spring rolls to complement the delicate dumplings. A little later, the main dishes arrived: grouper with fresh vegetables and orange chicken. I was personally more partial to the grouper, which was light to the touch and accompanied by the best tasting green beans I can recall, prepared in a way which kept them bright green and firm for eating. Yum. This meal cost less than any dinner on the trip, but really worked for us.
By contrast, in Quebec City, we had three multiple course meals. Each meal was a total experience. We were served one course at a time and each one had its time. This was particularly true of the restaurant Verla, which was promoted as being value-priced Italian, but turned out to be much higher end in all respects. We had an incredible dining experience, but it included a full two and one half hours devoted to the dinner and up to 30 minutes between courses. Everyone except my youngest son loved this place, but it was off the charts when we totalled up the bill. Still, our experience there symbolized the difference between the Quebec City and Montreal dining experiences. In Quebec City, dining is a passion. In its ideal form, you will sit down for up to three hours and have time to savor each course, while taking the time to enjoy a full bottle of wine.
In Montreal, there is a lot more going on. So dining is just one of the things to do and much less time seems to be devoted to it. As indicated by our Chinatown experience, it can still be marvelous, but the diner needs to be more careful in their selections and perhaps have lesser expectations. I love both places and now have had a chance to share both of them with my family, but the cities are very different experiences.
Do you want to enjoy a taste of Europe in North America and to bring home dining experiences to savor? Please, head off to Quebec City and enjoy the intimate experience offered by this special ville. But for the more cosmopolitan experience with many more things to do, head to Montreal, another unique city on the water. Either choice is a good one, but you'll have dramatically different experiences based on which city you choose.